Is Acrylic vs Tile Better for Showers?

When remodeling your bathroom, one of the crucial decisions is choosing between acrylic vs tile showers. Both options have their unique advantages and disadvantages. In this blog post, we’ll compare acrylic and tile showers to help you make an informed choice.

The Cost Factor

Material vs. Labor

One of the primary considerations is cost. Interestingly, the cost difference between acrylic vs tile showers is not substantial. Acrylic showers cost more in terms of material, while tile showers are labor-intensive, making the labor cost higher. Ultimately, the overall expense tends to balance out.

Aesthetic Appeal and Customization

Tile Showers: A Luxurious Choice

Tile is often considered the more luxurious option. It offers a wide range of customization possibilities, allowing homeowners to choose from various colors, patterns, and textures. In high-value homes, installing tile may be beneficial as future buyers might view acrylic as less prestigious. However, it is essential to remember that tile showers require maintenance, especially the grout. Regular sealing can prolong the life of your shower.

Acrylic Showers: Low Maintenance and Practical

On the other hand, acrylic showers are much easier to clean and maintain. They are an excellent choice for those who prefer low maintenance. This feature makes acrylic showers ideal for older individuals or rental properties where tenants might not be as diligent about upkeep. Acrylic showers are durable and require minimal maintenance, aside from occasional silicone replacement.

Maintenance and Durability

Tile Showers: Maintenance Required

While tile showers can last over ten years with proper care, they require regular maintenance. Grout needs periodic sealing and can eventually need replacing. Keeping up with grout maintenance is crucial to ensure the longevity and appearance of your tile shower.

Acrylic Showers: Easy Upkeep

Acrylic showers are virtually maintenance-free. They are designed to be durable and long-lasting, with the primary maintenance task being the replacement of silicone. This ease of upkeep makes acrylic showers an attractive option for many homeowners.

The Best Fit for Your Home

High-Value Homes

For high-value homes, tile showers may be the better option due to their luxurious appeal and customization options. Potential buyers often perceive tile showers as high-end, which can add value to your property.

Rental Properties and Low-Maintenance Preferences

In rental properties or for homeowners seeking minimal maintenance, acrylic showers are ideal. They offer durability and ease of cleaning, making them perfect for busy individuals or older adults.

Expert Installation Matters

Envy Home Services: Your Remodeling Experts

At Envy Home Services, we specialize in both tile and acrylic shower installations. As a veteran-owned local bathroom remodeler, we have installed hundreds of showers throughout the Chicagoland area. Our premier team of administrators and craftsmen ensures a seamless remodeling experience from start to finish.

Quality Craftsmanship

We pride ourselves on delivering top-notch craftsmanship, whether you’re opting for a tile or acrylic shower. Our team pays attention to every detail, ensuring your shower is not only beautiful but also built to last.

Free In-Home Quote

Considering a bathroom remodel? Contact Envy Home Services today for a free in-home quote. We’ll help you determine the best option for your needs and provide expert guidance throughout the process.

Conclusion: Acrylic vs Tile Shower

In the debate of acrylic vs tile showers, the best choice depends on your preferences and needs. Tile showers offer luxury and customization but require maintenance. Acrylic showers provide durability and low maintenance, making them ideal for many homeowners. Both options have their unique benefits, and at Envy Home Services, we’re here to help you make the right decision for your home. Call us today and start your journey to a beautifully remodeled bathroom!

See Our Past Work

​