Is It Cheaper to Reface Cabinets or Replace Them?

When it comes to kitchen renovations, one of the most common dilemmas homeowners face is deciding whether to cabinet refacing or replacing the cabinet is better. Both options have their pros and cons, but from a financial perspective, refacing often turns out to be more cost-effective. However, there are scenarios where the costs of both can align closely. Understanding these factors will help you make a more informed decision.

What is Cabinet Refacing?

Cabinet refacing involves replacing the visible cabinet components—mainly the doors and drawer fronts—and applying a new veneer over the existing cabinet boxes. It’s a process that dramatically changes the look of your cabinets without the need to replace the entire framework. Refacing is not only less disruptive but also more environmentally friendly and can often be completed in a much shorter time compared to full cabinet replacement.

When Refacing is the Cheaper Option

Minimal Changes with Maximum Impact

If your main goal is to update the style or color of your cabinets, then cabinet refacing is your best bet. This method allows you to transform the aesthetics of your kitchen without the extensive costs and efforts associated with full replacements. You don’t need to pull a building permit for cabinet refacing, making it a straightforward project compared to more extensive renovations.

Custom Sizing Considerations

For those with custom-sized cabinets, refacing becomes significantly more cost-effective. Creating new custom cabinets from scratch can be prohibitively expensive. In contrast, refacing utilizes the existing structure, which can be modified at a much lower cost. Typically, cabinet refacing costs between 25% to 50% less than installing new stock or custom cabinets.

Situations Where Replacing Might Be Similar in Cost or Cheaper

Major Layout Changes

If you’re planning significant layout changes, replacing cabinets might become necessary. Refacing works best when the existing layout remains largely unchanged. Adding new cabinets to match the refaced ones or building custom structures to suit a new design can escalate costs, potentially making new, standard stock cabinets a more economical choice.

Countertop Replacement and Building Permits

Replacing cabinets often requires replacing countertops due to damage incurred during the removal of the old cabinets. Additionally, significant cabinet replacements might necessitate a building permit, and you may need to update electrical and plumbing systems to meet local codes. These requirements add to the cost and complexity of the project.

Cost Comparison and Considerations

To determine the most cost-effective route, consider the scope of your renovation:

• Refacing: Best for aesthetic updates or when existing cabinets are still in good structural condition. Saves time and money by utilizing the existing cabinet framework.
• Replacing: Ideal for extensive kitchen remodels, layout changes, or when cabinets are in poor condition and need complete removal.

Refacing your cabinets can often save you 25% to 50% compared to the cost of full replacement, especially if no significant structural changes are needed.

Conclusion: Making the Economical Choice

Ultimately, if your goal is simply to update the look of your kitchen, cabinet refacing offers a significantly cheaper and equally effective alternative to complete cabinet replacement. You can achieve a fresh, new look while avoiding the additional expenses and complexities associated with changing layouts, updating countertops, and meeting new building codes.

Why Choose Envy Home Services for Your Cabinet Refacing?

Envy Home Services is a veteran-owned company specializing in cabinet refacing, serving Illinois residents with pride. With over 17 years of experience, our skilled team of administrators and installers ensures that your remodeling project runs smoothly from start to finish. Trust us to deliver high-quality, cost-effective solutions for your kitchen renovation needs. Contact us today for a free in-home quote and discover how we can transform your kitchen with minimal disruption and maximum efficiency.

See Our Work